The short version
Public health insurance is based on solidarity: everyone pays a percentage of their income and receives the same legally defined benefits. Private health insurance is based on an individual contract: you pay for the risk and the benefits you have chosen, whatever you earn.
| Topic | Public (GKV) | Private (PKV) |
|---|---|---|
| Who can join | Almost everyone. Compulsory for employees up to the income threshold. | Employees above €84,150 a year (2027, expected), self-employed people, civil servants and some other groups. |
| How the price is set | A percentage of your gross income, up to a ceiling. | Age at entry, health and chosen benefits. |
| Family | Spouse without own income and children are insured for free. | Every person has their own contract and premium. |
| Benefits | Defined by law, the same for all members. | Defined in your contract and chosen by you. |
| Paying the doctor | The doctor bills the insurer directly. | You receive the invoice and are reimbursed. |
| Health assessment | None. | Yes, before the contract starts. |
| Switching | Leaving is possible if you meet the conditions. | Returning to GKV is restricted, and generally not possible from age 55. |
Cost today
In the public system your contribution rises with your salary until it reaches the contribution ceiling. Your employer pays half. High earners therefore pay the maximum contribution, whether they are single or have a family of five.
In the private system a young, healthy person often pays less than the public maximum for more extensive benefits. Employees receive an employer contribution of half the premium, up to a legal cap. The premium does not change when your salary changes.
Cost in the future
This is where the decision deserves the most attention. Private premiums rise over time, mainly because medical treatment becomes more expensive and people live longer. Insurers build up ageing provisions from your premiums to soften this, but they cannot rule out increases. Public contributions also rise, through higher contribution rates and a higher ceiling.
In retirement the public contribution is calculated from your pension and certain other income. The private premium stays what it is, whatever your pension is. Privately insured pensioners can apply for a subsidy from the statutory pension insurance. Anyone choosing private insurance should plan for the premium in old age from the start, for example by setting aside part of what they save today.
Family
For families the public system has a clear advantage: a spouse without their own income and children are covered at no extra cost. In the private system each child and each adult needs their own contract. For singles and for couples with two good incomes this matters little. For a family with one earner it can be the deciding factor.
Benefits and treatment
Public insurance covers what is medically necessary, as defined by law. That catalogue is broad, but it can be changed by legislation, and some things have limits, for example dental prosthetics or glasses.
In private insurance you decide on the level of cover when you sign: which share of dental costs is reimbursed, whether you have a one-bed room in hospital, whether treatment by a senior consultant is included. These benefits are set out in your contract, and the insurer can only change the terms in narrow exceptions defined by law. Doctors bill private patients under a separate fee schedule, and some practices offer private patients earlier appointments, although there is no entitlement to this.
Health assessment
Public insurers accept every eligible person without asking about their health. Private insurers ask detailed health questions. Existing conditions can lead to a surcharge or an exclusion, and sometimes to a rejection. This is why it is usually easier and cheaper to join when you are young and healthy, and why honest answers in the application are so important.
Flexibility
You can move between public insurers quite easily. Moving from public to private is possible once you are eligible. Moving back is the hard direction. It normally requires a change in your circumstances, such as a salary below the threshold, and it is generally closed from the age of 55. Within private insurance you have a legal right to change to another plan with the same insurer and to keep the ageing provisions you have built up.
Which one fits you?
Private insurance often fits if you earn well above the threshold or are self-employed with a stable income, if you are young and healthy, if you value a defined, higher level of cover and if you are prepared to plan for the premium in old age.
Public insurance often fits if you have or plan a family on one income, if your income varies a lot, if you have health conditions or if you may want to work part-time for longer periods.
I am a tied insurance agent for ARAG, so I can show you what a private plan from ARAG would cost and cover. I do not sell public insurance, and I will not talk you out of it if it is the better fit. A first call in English is free.
